Structured elicitation of expert judgement in real-time eruption scenarios: An exercise for Piton de la Fournaise volcano, La Réunion island

Alessandro Tadini; Andrew J. L. Harris; Julie Morin; Andrea Bevilacqua; Aline Peltier; Willy Aspinall; Stefano Ciolli; Patrick Bachelery; Benjamin Bernard; Jonas Biren; Antonio Brum da Silveira; Valery Cayol; Oryaelle Chevrel; Diego Coppola; Hannah R. Dietterich; Amy Donovan; Olaya Dorado; Stephane Drenne; Olivier Dupere; Lucia Gurioli; Stephan Kolzenburg; Jean-Christophe Komorowski; Philippe Labazuy; Domenico Mangione; Stefano Mannini; Francois Martel-Asselin; Etienne Medard; Sophie Pailot-Bonnetat; Victoria Rafflin; Michael Ramsey; Nicole Richter; Silvia Vallejo-Vargas; Nicolas Villeneuve; Silvia Zafrilla

doi:10.30909/vol.05.01.105131

Home/Archive/USGS

USGS · 70231752

Structured elicitation of expert judgement in real-time eruption scenarios: An exercise for Piton de la Fournaise volcano, La Réunion island

View original source ↗Export metadata ↓

Abstract

Formalised elicitation of expert judgements has been used to help tackle several problematic societal issues, including volcanic crises and pandemic threats. We present an expert elicitation exercise for Piton de la Fournaise volcano, La Réunion island, held remotely in April 2021. This involved 28 experts from nine countries who considered a hypothetical effusive eruption crisis involving a new vent opening in a high-risk area. The tele-elicitation presented several challenges, but is a promising and workable option for application to future volcanic crises. Our exercise considered an “uncommon” eruptive scenario with a vent outside the present caldera and within inhabited areas, and provided uncertainty ranges for several hazard-related questions for such a scenario (e.g. probability of eruption within a defined timeframe; elapsed time until lava flow reaches a critical location, and other hazard management issues). Our exercise indicated that such a scenario would probably present very different characteristics compared to recent eruptions, and that it is fundamental to include well-prepared expert elicitations in updated civil protection evacuation plans to improve disaster response procedures.

Explore related subjects

Volcanica Article

Source-reported bounding extent: -21.423668314313243° to -20.820308271198467° latitude; 55.15960693359375° to 55.85723876953125° longitude. This indicates report coverage, not an exact sampling location. View area on OpenStreetMap.

Keep this discovery

Explore connections, maps & timelines

BibTeX RIS

Alessandro Tadini, Andrew J. L. Harris, Julie Morin, Andrea Bevilacqua, Aline Peltier, Willy Aspinall, Stefano Ciolli, Patrick Bachelery, Benjamin Bernard, Jonas Biren, Antonio Brum da Silveira, Valery Cayol, Oryaelle Chevrel, Diego Coppola, Hannah R. Dietterich, Amy Donovan, Olaya Dorado, Stephane Drenne, Olivier Dupere, Lucia Gurioli, Stephan Kolzenburg, Jean-Christophe Komorowski, Philippe Labazuy, Domenico Mangione, Stefano Mannini, Francois Martel-Asselin, Etienne Medard, Sophie Pailot-Bonnetat, Victoria Rafflin, Michael Ramsey, Nicole Richter, Silvia Vallejo-Vargas, Nicolas Villeneuve, Silvia Zafrilla. 2022-05-05. Structured elicitation of expert judgement in real-time eruption scenarios: An exercise for Piton de la Fournaise volcano, La Réunion island. https://doi.org/10.30909/vol.05.01.105131

Cite the original work for its findings. Save a collection to share your selection of sources.

KEEP EXPLORING

Related USGS reports

USGS2026

The fluorine dichotomy: Amphibole control on fluorine availability during magmatic differentiation

Experimental and observational evidence suggests that water and fluorine (F) are incompatible in silicate minerals and originate from similar sources in the mantle. This, in turn, suggests that F and water should coevolve in magmatic systems. However, hydrous subduction zone (“arc”) magmas are depleted in F relative to anhydrous magmas. We explore this apparent dichotomy in fluorine’s behavior by examining amphibole, which preferentially incorporates F into its crystal structure. By developing a parametrized fluorine amphibole/silicate melt partition coefficient for F, we show that F concentrations in calculated equilibrium melts in arc systems do not increase with differentiation. This indicates that F behaves compatibly in hydrous arc magmas due to sequestration in amphibole-bearing arc cumulates. In dry magmatic systems, where amphibole does not crystallize, we show that F behaves incompatibly during differentiation, resulting in F enrichment in evolved magmas. These results have implications for the formation of ore deposits associated with elements that complex with F, such as rare-earth elements.

Volcanica↗

USGS2026

A scanning electron microscope-energy dispersive spectrometry (SEM-EDS) method for the quantitative analysis of common volcanic phases

In situ microanalysis by X-ray spectrometry is a fundamental geochemical technique for volcanology and the geosciences generally and typically performed using an electron microprobe (EPMA) equipped with wavelength dispersive spectrometers (WDS). The related technique of energy dispersive spectrometry (EDS), implemented using either EPMA or a scanning electron microscope (SEM), offers advantages in throughput, simplicity, and cost, yet has historically been relegated to qualitative tasks. We present a quantitative EDS procedure implemented using a W-source SEM and a moderate size silicon drift EDS detector applied to common volcanic materials. Glass and mineral standard data demonstrate that the accuracy and precision of this method is comparable to EPMA–WDS. We show that electron beam damage can be mitigated in volcanic glass through sample-specific optimizations without the need for a time-dependent intensity correction. Our implementation using a relatively inexpensive instrument can potentially increase the accessibility of high-quality, quantitative X-ray microanalysis of major and minor elements.

Volcanica↗

USGS2026

Relating glassy rind thicknesses to ambient air temperatures at the Lost Jim flow field in the Imuruk Lake volcanic field, Alaska

The Lost Jim flow field, in the Imuruk Lake volcanic field, Alaska, extends west ~34 km from a single vent, crossing subarctic tundra and currently touches several lakes and streams. The weighted mean of five 36Cl cosmogenic exposure ages from the Lost Jim pāhoehoe flow is 7.73 ± 0.37 ka, indicating this eruption occurred substantially after the eruption of the underlying Camille flow, which was emplaced at 39.7 ± 1.3 ka. Paleoclimate records indicate the period when the Lost Jim flow field was emplaced was after deglaciation, and the climate was similar to today. We propose that the emplacement of lava in these cold subarctic conditions can lead to faster cooling of the lava surface compared to lava emplaced in warmer locations such as mid- latitude cold deserts. Glass abundance in the outermost rinds at the Lost Jim flow field was on average 74 % with 6.4 mm thick rims, compared to 60 % with 2.9 mm rims for cold mid-latitude desert samples. We interpret increased glass content as a proxy for rapid cooling likely occurring partly during winter. Glassiness values varied less across vent, margin, and mid-flow locations when compared to the mid-latitude flows suggesting the Lost Jim flow field was broadly impacted by the subarctic climate as opposed to responding to local microclimates. Our results indicate that lava glassiness may be a useful environmental indicator of cooler (in this case subarctic) conditions.

Alaska↗