USGS Science⌕ Search
Home/Archive/USGS

USGS · 1000853

Selecting Great Lakes streams for lampricide treatment based on larval sea lamprey surveys

Gavin C. Christie·Jean V. Adams·Todd B. Steeves·Jeffrey W. Slade·Douglas W. Cuddy·Michael F. Fodale·Robert J. Young·Miroslaw Kuc·Michael L. Jones
View original source ↗Export metadata ↓

Abstract

The Empiric Stream Treatment Ranking (ESTR) system is a data-driven, model-based, decision tool for selecting Great Lakes streams for treatment with lampricide, based on estimates from larval sea lamprey ( Petromyzon marinus ) surveys conducted throughout the basin. The 2000 ESTR system was described and applied to larval assessment surveys conducted from 1996 to 1999. A comparative analysis of stream survey and selection data was conducted and improvements to the stream selection process were recommended. Streams were selected for treatment based on treatment cost, predicted treatment effectiveness, and the projected number of juvenile sea lampreys produced. On average, lampricide treatments were applied annually to 49 streams with 1,075 ha of larval habitat, killing 15 million larval and 514,000 juvenile sea lampreys at a total cost of $5.3 million, and marginal and mean costs of $85 and $10 per juvenile killed. The numbers of juvenile sea lampreys killed for given treatment costs showed a pattern of diminishing returns with increasing investment. Of the streams selected for treatment, those with > 14 ha of larval habitat targeted 73% of the juvenile sea lampreys for 60% of the treatment cost. Suggested improvements to the ESTR system were to improve accuracy and precision of model estimates, account for uncertainty in estimates, include all potentially productive streams in the process (not just those surveyed in the current year), consider the value of all larvae killed during treatment (not just those predicted to metamorphose the following year), use lake-specific estimates of damage, and establish formal suppression targets.

Explore related subjects

Journal of Great Lakes ResearchArticle

Keep this discovery

Explore connections, maps & timelines

BibTeXRIS

Gavin C. Christie, Jean V. Adams, Todd B. Steeves, Jeffrey W. Slade, Douglas W. Cuddy, Michael F. Fodale, Robert J. Young, Miroslaw Kuc, Michael L. Jones. 2003. Selecting Great Lakes streams for lampricide treatment based on larval sea lamprey surveys. https://doi.org/10.1016/s0380-1330(03)70484-5

Cite the original work for its findings. Save a collection to share your selection of sources.

KEEP EXPLORING

Related USGS reports

USGS2026

Groundwater nutrient contributions to surface water in the upper Maumee River basin

Harmful algal blooms triggered by nutrient loading have negatively affected Lake Erie water quality for decades, but the role groundwater plays in transporting nutrients to tributary streams is unclear. Here, we apply a multi-scale approach to investigate groundwater nitrogen (N) and phosphorus (P) dynamics at the field scale, along a groundwater flow path, and at the Maumee River basin scale. Unsaturated zone monitoring indicates that macropore flow is the primary mechanism for N and P leaching with nitrate and orthophosphate (OP) concentrations from macropore samplers more than double those from soil-matrix samplers. Shallow (< 4.5 m) groundwater nitrate concentrations indicate the timing of saturated-zone nitrate fluxes is crop dependent with more nitrate mobilized during the maize growing season whereas concentrations below soybeans can remain elevated (> 3 mg/L) through winter months. A three-end-member hydrograph analysis for the upper Maumee River basin indicates that tile drains transport most subsurface N and P with greater than 15,000 kg per day of nitrate transported between January and May. Orthophosphate concentrations in tile drainage at an edge-of-field site correlate well with concentrations in a nearby tributary of the Maumee River. While runoff is the dominant source of OP loading, tile drainage and groundwater discharge contributed an estimated 36% of OP load during a 2018–2022 analysis period with most subsurface loading occurring between January and March. These findings highlight how best management practices (such as cover crops and tile drainage control structures) can be used to help limit leaching and tile effluent during the nongrowing season.

Indiana↗
USGS2026

Low recapture rates preclude survival estimates of larval and juvenile sea lamprey in the Lake Erie basin

Our goal was to estimate survival of non-native larval and juvenile sea lamprey ( Petromyzon marinus ) in the Lake Erie basin and compare estimates with those from Lakes Huron and Michigan. Accomplishing the goal would inform decisions about allocating limited control resources among the Laurentian Great Lakes to protect valued fish stocks. Between 2012 and 2018, coded-wire tagged (CWT) larvae and juveniles were released in three Lake Erie tributaries where they were unlikely to experience control program-induced mortality. Adult sea lamprey returning to tributaries to spawn were captured and scanned for CWTs, with the objectives being to determine (1) if survival differed between the Saint Clair River and other sea lamprey-producing tributaries of Lake Erie, and (2) if survival in Lake Erie differed from estimates in Lakes Huron and Michigan. No tagged larvae were recaptured as adults, preventing survival estimation. Recovery probability of tagged juveniles released in the Saint Clair River in the adult stage was about half that of other streams, but statistical comparisons were limited due to low recovery (Objective 1). Estimated lake-wide adult sea lamprey abundance was at record lows when tagged larvae were expected to return as adults. Simulations suggest that survival estimates of larval and juvenile sea lamprey in Lake Erie may be less than survival estimated in Lakes Huron and Michigan (Objective 2). Understanding survival rates of sea lamprey across the Great Lakes and individual streams could guide control effort allocation, although alternative methods for quantifying survival may be needed given the challenges encountered here.

Lake Erie basin↗
USGS2026

Short-term outcomes of juvenile sea lamprey feeding on lake trout vary among parasite–host number combinations in a controlled laboratory setting

The parasitic juvenile stage of the invasive sea lamprey ( Petromyzon marinus ) causes host injury and mortality in the Laurentian Great Lakes, yet laboratory feeding studies have generally used single-host or simple host-choice designs. We conducted controlled 7-d trials to quantify lake trout ( Salvelinus namaycush ) wounding, sea lamprey recovery, positive net mass change, growth, and wound location across four lamprey–host number combinations: 1:3, 6:6, 6:3, and 18:9. Candidate models evaluated whether outcomes were better explained by number combination, lamprey abundance, lamprey:host ratio, or separate lamprey and host effects. Across 27 trials, 70 of 135 lake trout (51.9%) were wounded, producing 113 wounds. Wounding was lowest in 1:3 (sea lamprey:host) and highest in 18:9, where 72.2% of hosts were wounded, and wound intensity was 1.33 wounds per host. In pooled descriptive models, each additional stocked sea lamprey was associated with a 13% increase in the odds that an exposed lake trout was wounded and an 8.3% increase in wound intensity per host. Among 173 recovered sea lamprey, 104 (60.1%) exhibited positive net mass change. This probability varied among number combinations, whereas candidate predictors provided little improvement over constant-mean models for continuous growth. Among lamprey exhibiting positive net mass change, intercept-only models were best supported, indicating little evidence that growth magnitude varied systematically among combinations. Wounds were distributed non-randomly among host body regions relative to proportional surface area. Short-term outcomes, therefore, varied among the tested parasite–host number combinations.

Journal of Great Lakes Research↗