Hydrologic budgets and water availability of six bedrock aquifers in the Black Hills area, South Dakota and Wyoming, 1931–2022

Abstract

Population growth and recurring droughts in the Black Hills region raised interest in water resources and future availability. The Black Hills hydrology study (BHHS) was initiated in the early 1990s to address questions regarding water resources. Since completion of the BHHS in the early 2000s, the population of the Black Hills region increased by about 39 percent, which has renewed interest in water demand and availability in the Black Hills. The U.S. Geological Survey, in cooperation with the Western Dakota Regional Water System, completed a study to update hydrologic budgets from the BHHS for six of the most used aquifers in the Black Hills. Water availability was determined by comparing results from hydrologic budgets to modern well withdrawals (2003–22) and water rights information. Key updates to the BHHS budgets included adding available data from 1999 to 2022 and determining hydrologic budgets for six aquifers in nine smaller areas (called “subareas”). Inflows for the hydrologic budget included recharge from precipitation and streamflow losses to aquifers. Total mean annual recharge for the six aquifers in the study area was estimated at 278,900 acre-feet, with 205,100 acre-feet from precipitation recharge and 73,800 acre-feet from streamflow recharge. Mean annual precipitation recharge for the Madison and Minnelusa aquifers together accounted for 76 percent of the total mean annual precipitation recharge, with the Madison aquifer contributing 57,000 acre-feet and the Minnelusa aquifer contributing 98,100 acre-feet. Outflow components estimated for the hydrologic budget include artesian springflow and well withdrawals. Total mean annual artesian springflow in the study area was estimated as 166,100 acre-feet for the combined Madison and Minnelusa aquifers. Mean total annual well withdrawals for 2003–22 in the study area were about 50,000 acre-feet. No increased well withdrawal patterns corresponding to population increases were observed between 2003 and 2022. Water availability was determined by comparing total annual appropriations and mean and maximum annual well withdrawals for 2003–22 to mean annual recharge for 1931–2022 for each aquifer in subareas 1–9. Modern well withdrawals (mean and maximum for 2003–22) exceeded mean annual recharge for only the Deadwood and Inyan Kara aquifers in subareas 9 and 4, respectively. Additionally, total annual appropriations did not exceed mean annual recharge in most subareas, except most notably in subarea 4 (Rapid City area) where appropriations exceeded recharge for the Madison, Minnelusa, and Inyan Kara aquifers. Total annual appropriations also exceeded mean annual recharge for the Inyan Kara aquifer in subareas 3 and 5. In addition to recharge, water availability includes the water stored in pore spaces of aquifer materials. Estimates of total volume of recoverable water in storage were updated as part of this study to include the portion of aquifers in Wyoming, which were omitted during the BHHS. In total, the estimated total amount of recoverable water in storage in the study area was 356.9 million acre-feet for six major aquifers in the Black Hills area of South Dakota and Wyoming.