Dynamic treeline and cryosphere response to pronounced mid-Holocene climatic variability in the US Rocky Mountains

Gregory T. Pederson; Daniel K. Stahle; David B McWethy; Matthew Toohey; Johann Jungclaus; Craig Lee; Justin T. Martin; Mio Alt; Nickolas E. Kichas; Nathan J. Chellman; Joseph R. McConnell; Cathy Whitlock

doi:10.1073/pnas.2412162121

USGS · 70261894

Dynamic treeline and cryosphere response to pronounced mid-Holocene climatic variability in the US Rocky Mountains

Gregory T. Pederson·Daniel K. Stahle·David B McWethy·Matthew Toohey·Johann Jungclaus·Craig Lee·Justin T. Martin·Mio Alt·Nickolas E. Kichas·Nathan J. Chellman·Joseph R. McConnell·Cathy Whitlock

View original source ↗Export metadata ↓

Abstract

Climate-driven changes in high-elevation forest distribution and reductions in snow and ice cover have major implications for ecosystems and global water security. In the Greater Yellowstone Ecosystem of the Rocky Mountains (United States), recent melting of a high-elevation (3,091 m asl) ice patch exposed a mature stand of whitebark pine ( Pinus albicaulis ) trees, located ~180 m in elevation above modern treeline, that date to the mid-Holocene (c. 5,950 to 5,440 cal y BP). Here, we used this subfossil wood record to develop tree-ring-based temperature estimates for the upper-elevation climate conditions that resulted in ancient forest establishment and growth and the subsequent regional ice-patch growth and downslope shift of treeline. Results suggest that mid-Holocene forest establishment and growth occurred under warm-season (May-Oct) mean temperatures of 6.2 °C (±0.2 °C), until a multicentury cooling anomaly suppressed temperatures below 5.8 °C, resulting in stand mortality by c. 5,440 y BP. Transient climate model simulations indicate that regional cooling was driven by changes in summer insolation and Northern Hemisphere volcanism. The initial cooling event was followed centuries later (c. 5,100 y BP) by sustained Icelandic volcanic eruptions that forced a centennial-scale 1.0 °C summer cooling anomaly and led to rapid ice-patch growth and preservation of the trees. With recent warming (c. 2000–2020 CE), warm-season temperatures now equal and will soon exceed those of the mid-Holocene period of high treeline. It is likely that perennial ice cover will again disappear from the region, and treeline may expand upslope so long as plant-available moisture and disturbance are not limiting.

Explore related subjects

Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences Article

Source-reported bounding extent: 44.77582421595028° to 45.200185933759144° latitude; -110.40405049321484° to -109.75503610328678° longitude. This indicates report coverage, not an exact sampling location. View area on OpenStreetMap.

Keep this discovery

Explore connections, maps & timelines

BibTeX RIS

Gregory T. Pederson, Daniel K. Stahle, David B McWethy, Matthew Toohey, Johann Jungclaus, Craig Lee, Justin T. Martin, Mio Alt, Nickolas E. Kichas, Nathan J. Chellman, Joseph R. McConnell, Cathy Whitlock. 2024-12-30. Dynamic treeline and cryosphere response to pronounced mid-Holocene climatic variability in the US Rocky Mountains. https://doi.org/10.1073/pnas.2412162121

Cite the original work for its findings. Save a collection to share your selection of sources.

KEEP EXPLORING

Related USGS reports

USGS2026

Extensive glacier loss in the coterminous United States

Glaciers populate the mountain ranges of the western conterminous United States and despite their importance to alpine hydrology, their area and volume change have never been comprehensively evaluated. Since the mid-Twentieth Century about one-quarter of the glaciers have disappeared and the overall area and volume are reduced by one-third. The pattern of glacier shrinkage suggests most glaciers in the Conterminous US are largely maintained by local topographic influences due to their small size. These results are critical to understanding evolving high alpine hydrology and important to ecosystem processes.

conterminous United States↗

USGS2026

Oak masting breaks down in a highly fragmented, pollen limited landscape

Masting, the production of variable and synchronous seed crops, is common among wind pollinated trees, and periodic pollen limitation is thought to be an important component of the process of masting. However, little is known either about the dynamics of mast seed production or pollen limitation in isolated trees. We tracked seed production of valley oak ( Quercus lobata ) over 11 years in a highly fragmented landscape in California’s Central Valley in which many trees lacked conspecific neighbors within 500 m. We found that oaks with closer neighbors produced more acorns on average than oaks with fewer neighbors. Consistent with theories linking mast seeding and pollination, the isolation effect was most apparent in the highest seed production years. While individual trees showed substantial interannual variation in seed production, we observed little synchrony in seed production among individuals compared to intact oak populations throughout California. Our results indicate that highly fragmented populations suffer signs of pollen limitation and do not produce synchronous seed crops. Fragmentation, alongside climate change, is a dimension of global change that interrupts the typical seed production dynamics of trees.

California↗

USGS2026

Deep critical zone controls on shallow landslides

The deep critical zone (CZ) has long been recognized for its importance in influencing shallow landslides but was not considered feasible to include in slope stability models at the watershed scale. In this study, we demonstrate that simple approximations of the CZ in a fully coupled hydrologic and soil slope stability model can effectively capture the location, timing, and likely size of shallow landslides. To achieve this, we use coupled, process-based models that incorporate the effects of 1) deep CZ structures, 2) three-dimensional transient hydrology, and 3) multidimensional slope stability, calibrated with data from an intensively monitored field site. Our results show that the hydrologically active deep CZ guides groundwater flow, influencing where it drains from or exfiltrates to the soil mantle, producing distinct patterns of soil saturation and seepage forces at the soil-bedrock boundary. Deep conductive weathered critical zone drains the soil mantle, reducing the likelihood of destabilizing pore pressures, while the downslope thinning of the CZ forces groundwater to the surface. This creates localized instability and a tendency for similar-sized landslides across the landscape. In contrast, the absence of conductive weathered bedrock results in more widespread destabilizing pore pressures, leading to larger landslides and the likelihood of landslides earlier in a storm than in landscapes underlain by a deep CZ. Our findings suggest that first-order variations of deep CZ can provide physical explanations for variations observed in the susceptibility, magnitude, and timing of shallow landslides, and that CZ structure may be inferred from patterns and timing of landsliding.

Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences↗