Effects of elk and bison herbivory on narrowleaf cottonwood

Linda C. Zeigenfuss; Kathryn A. Schoenecker

doi:10.3398/064.081.0109

Home/Archive/USGS

USGS · 70228936

Effects of elk and bison herbivory on narrowleaf cottonwood

Linda C. Zeigenfuss·Kathryn A. Schoenecker

View original source ↗Export metadata ↓

Abstract

Ungulate browsing influences the structure and composition of woody plant communities, including species composition and biomass production as well as age distribution, recruitment, and mortality. We evaluated effects of elk and bison herbivory on narrowleaf cottonwood ( Populus angustifolia ) communities in a semiarid ecosystem in southern Colorado. Cottonwoods in this ecosystem have been aged at ≥300 years old and are among the oldest cottonwood trees in North America. We compared browsing intensity and structural and productivity responses of cottonwood to ungulate herbivory. We compared responses in sites with elk and bison, sites with elk but no bison, and sites where both ungulates were excluded. We found that the majority of browsing on cottonwood occurred during summer in this high desert ecosystem. Areas with both elk and bison had higher browse utilization than areas with only elk, but diet data indicated that elk consumed a much greater proportion of cottonwood than bison. Overall, browse utilization observed in this study was low to moderate compared to other studies, and our results may not be representative of sites experiencing intense year-round herbivory. Removal of all ungulate herbivory led to taller and denser cottonwood suckers; however, other environmental factors, in addition to herbivory, still strongly limit cottonwood growth and recruitment in this ecosystem.

Explore related subjects

Western North American Naturalist Article

Source-reported bounding extent: 37.615319243559085° to 37.996162679728116° latitude; -105.80795288085936° to -105.40557861328125° longitude. This indicates report coverage, not an exact sampling location. View area on OpenStreetMap.

Keep this discovery

Explore connections, maps & timelines

BibTeX RIS

Linda C. Zeigenfuss, Kathryn A. Schoenecker. 2021. Effects of elk and bison herbivory on narrowleaf cottonwood. https://doi.org/10.3398/064.081.0109

Cite the original work for its findings. Save a collection to share your selection of sources.

KEEP EXPLORING

Related USGS reports

USGS2026

Interspecific brood parasitism of a greater sage-grouse brood by chukar in Nevada

Greater sage-grouse ( Centrocercus urophasianus ; hereafter, sage-grouse) populations have declined across their range, resulting in high conservation concerns among state and federal wildlife managers. While interspecific nest parasitism by chukar ( Alectoris chukar ) on sage-grouse nests has been observed previously, the parasitic effects benefiting or harming the reproduction of either species are unknown. Additionally, while chukar eggs have been documented in sage-grouse nests previously, we know of no documented occurrences of chukar chicks parasitizing sage-grouse broods. Here, we report a novel observation of interspecific brood parasitism on a 9-day-old sage-grouse brood by a chukar chick in the Virginia Mountains of northwestern Nevada. Because chukar are an introduced exotic species whose western North American distribution largely overlaps sage-grouse distribution, understanding the dynamics and implications of brood parasitism may inform wildlife management strategies and conservation efforts for sage-grouse throughout their range.

Nevada↗

USGS2025

Pleistocene porcupine (Erethizontidae) records in arid southwestern North America and comparisons with the modern distribution of Erethizon dorsatum in southern California and Arizona

he North American porcupine ( Erethizon dorsatum ) is widely distributed throughout many ecosystems on the continent from northern Mexico to the Arctic Ocean, except for the southeastern portion of the United States. Habitats include the arid Desert Southwest region where modern records are generally sparse. The paleogeographic range in the Desert Southwest is not unlike the modern distribution of Erethizon , with some exceptions. Although there are early Pleistocene records of Erethizon for southern California, no late Pleistocene records (Rancholabrean North American Land Mammal Age [NALMA]) are known for Imperial, Inyo, Riverside, or San Bernardino Counties in southern California or in Mexico. This is surprising given late-Pleistocene records in Arizona, Nevada, and New Mexico and modern records from southern California and Mexico. Pleistocene habitats for porcupines were similar to those occupied today, just at different elevations due to differing climates. Modern preferred habitats in the Desert Southwest include conifer-clad high-elevation areas and associated pinyon pine / juniper belts, and occasionally riparian corridors in desert environments. The overall rarity of porcupines today in arid parts of the Desert Southwest is likely due to the combination of increasing aridity in the region during the Holocene, past persecution by humans, and increasing predator populations.

Arizona, California↗

USGS2025

Comparative life history of mud turtles (genus: Kinosternon) from the North American deserts

The warm deserts of North America are characterized by diverse environments that include the transition zone between tropical and temperate regions on the continent. This vast region includes the Sonoran and Chihuahuan deserts, which have different precipitation regimes and are composed of different floras and faunas, separated by the Cochise Filter Barrier. Inhabiting these deserts are 7 mud turtles (representing 4 separate clades within the genus Kinosternon ), and we compared their basic ecology, life history, and estivation time to test for variation between deserts. We used phylogenetic comparative methods to correlate the life history traits with environmental variables (temperature and precipitation) to test for variation between deserts. Life history strategies (clutch size, egg size, and reproductive phenology) of mud turtles were similar across both deserts, with negative correlations of clutch size and age of maturity with both aridity and temperature variables. Maximum estivation time was correlated with the seasonality of each included locality. Overall, life history strategies were quite similar, with small local specializations to avoid high temperatures and periodic lack of water. From a population ecology perspective, populations showed varied sex ratios biased toward males or females, along with different population structure among populations and species. However, most published studies lacked data for hatchlings. Phylogenetic signal is high in traits related to body size, including sexual size dimorphism. Overall, mud turtles from the southwest deserts are adapted to regional seasonality and precipitation regimes, with minor adjustments to fit local conditions.

Western North American Naturalist↗