Accounting for rate variation among lineages in comparative demographic analyses

Andrew G. Hope; Simon Y. W. Ho; Jason L. Malaney; Joseph A. Cook; Sandra L. Talbot

doi:10.1111/evo.12469

Home/Archive/USGS

USGS · 70147247

Accounting for rate variation among lineages in comparative demographic analyses

Andrew G. Hope·Simon Y. W. Ho·Jason L. Malaney·Joseph A. Cook·Sandra L. Talbot

View original source ↗Export metadata ↓

Abstract

Genetic analyses of contemporary populations can be used to estimate the demographic histories of species within an ecological community. Comparison of these demographic histories can shed light on community responses to past climatic events. However, species experience different rates of molecular evolution, and this presents a major obstacle to comparative demographic analyses. We address this problem by using a Bayesian relaxed-clock method to estimate the relative evolutionary rates of 22 small mammal taxa distributed across northwestern North America. We found that estimates of the relative molecular substitution rate for each taxon were consistent across the range of sampling schemes that we compared. Using three different reference rates, we rescaled the relative rates so that they could be used to estimate absolute evolutionary timescales. Accounting for rate variation among taxa led to temporal shifts in our skyline-plot estimates of demographic history, highlighting both uniform and idiosyncratic evolutionary responses to directional climate trends for distinct ecological subsets of the small mammal community. Our approach can be used in evolutionary analyses of populations from multiple species, including comparative demographic studies.

Explore related subjects

Evolution Article

Keep this discovery

Explore connections, maps & timelines

BibTeX RIS

Andrew G. Hope, Simon Y. W. Ho, Jason L. Malaney, Joseph A. Cook, Sandra L. Talbot. 2014-07-21. Accounting for rate variation among lineages in comparative demographic analyses. https://doi.org/10.1111/evo.12469

Cite the original work for its findings. Save a collection to share your selection of sources.

KEEP EXPLORING

Related USGS reports

USGS2026

Deconstructing cardiovascular and coagulation-related traits links dietary ecology to multi-functional snake venom specificity

Animal venoms vary greatly in compositional complexity, where complex venoms are hypothesized to be maintained by greater dietary breadth. Beyond explaining venom composition, the dietary breadth hypothesis predicts that these more complex venoms should show greater functional breadth in terms of overall toxicity and by disrupting multiple prey physiological processes. We evaluate these predictions with six distinct physiological assays of cardiac and blood clotting functions and compared the effects of venoms from snake species with a range of taxonomic dietary diversity levels. We compared the taxonomic dietary generalists Agkistrodon piscivorus and Sistrurus miliarius to taxa with varying taxonomic specialization, namely Ag. contortrix and Crotalus adamanteus , and Azemiops feae . Comparing fish thrombocyte and mammal platelet aggregation and fibrin clot formation, only species with broader diets disrupted both fish and mammal hemostatic function. Venom of Ag. piscivorus , a uniquely fish-eating species, was the most disruptive of zebrafish heart rate, thrombocyte activation, vascular permeability, and clotting after injury. Sistrurus miliarius was also highly toxic, whereas mammal-specialists’ venoms scarcely altered zebrafish physiology. Our results support the hypothesis that dietary breadth selects functionally complex venoms. Understanding venom gene evolution, snakebite symptoms, and searching for therapeutics in venom should be guided by evolutionary ecology.

Evolution↗

USGS2025

The role of ecology in allopatric speciation of darters in the Central Highlands, USA

Allopatric speciation is the predominant mode of speciation in riverine fishes. However, the relative importance of genetic drift versus natural selection in the allopatric speciation of these fishes remain uncertain. Here, we present a case study that demonstrates the role of ecology in the diversification of a group of imperiled freshwater fishes from the central United States. We integrate a phylogenomic dataset with analyses of streamwise distance, environmental variables, meristic and morphological traits, and diet to investigate the ecological context and outcomes of allopatric speciation within a species complex comprising the Slenderhead Darter Percina phoxocephala (Nelson), Ouachita Darter Percina brucethompsoni (Robison, Cashner, and Near), and Longnose Darter Percina nasuta (Bailey). We find that two of the species traditionally delimited based on disparity in snout length, P. phoxocephala and P. nasuta , are polyphyletic, revealing three instances of the parallel evolution of snout length disparity. We propose a revised taxonomy including the delimitation of six new species based on disparity in phenotypic traits and phylogenomic analyses. We find that morphological differences are not correlated with genetic divergence but are congruent with variations in diet and environmental niches, suggesting a role for ecological factors in allopatric speciation of riverine fishes.

Arkansas, Kansas, Missouri, Oklahoma↗

USGS2024

Asymmetric mate preference and reproductive interference mediate climate-induced changes in mate availability in a small mammal hybrid zone

Range expansion and contraction are among the most common biotic responses to changing environmental conditions, yet much is to be learned about the mechanisms that underlie range-edge population dynamics, especially when those areas are points of secondary contact between closely related species. Here, we present field-measured parentage data that document the reproductive outcomes of changes in mate availability at a secondary contact zone between two species of woodrat in the genus Neotoma . Changes in mate availability resulted from drought-driven differential survival between the species and their hybrids. As the availability of conspecifc mates declined, rates of hybridization increased, leading to the accumulation of admixed individuals in the zone of contact. Patterns of reproductive success in the wild appear to be the result of a combination of both pre-mating isolation and post-zygotic selection resulting from genomic incompatibilities between the parental lineages. Evidence of asymmetric mate preference between the parental lineages came from both skewed reproductive output in the field and laboratory preference trials. Moreover, partial genomic incompatibility was evident from the near-zero reproductive success of F1 males and because nearly all surviving hybrids had one pure parent. Nonetheless, the high reproductive success of F1 females and backcrossing in both parental directions allow for introgression between the parental species. These findings reveal how climate change may alter evolutionary outcomes for species at the edge of their ranges through an interplay of behavioral, demographic, and genetic mechanisms.

California↗