Effect of summer throughfall exclusion, summer drought, and winter snow cover on methane fluxes in a temperate forest soil

W. Borken; E.A. Davidson; K. Savage; E.T. Sundquist; P. Steudler

doi:10.1016/j.soilbio.2005.10.011

Home/Archive/USGS

USGS · 70030299

Effect of summer throughfall exclusion, summer drought, and winter snow cover on methane fluxes in a temperate forest soil

W. Borken·E.A. Davidson·K. Savage·E.T. Sundquist·P. Steudler

View original source ↗Export metadata ↓

Abstract

Soil moisture strongly controls the uptake of atmospheric methane by limiting the diffusion of methane into the soil, resulting in a negative correlation between soil moisture and methane uptake rates under most non-drought conditions. However, little is known about the effect of water stress on methane uptake in temperate forests during severe droughts. We simulated extreme summer droughts by exclusion of 168 mm (2001) and 344 mm (2002) throughfall using three translucent roofs in a mixed deciduous forest at the Harvard Forest, Massachusetts, USA. The treatment significantly increased CH4 uptake during the first weeks of throughfall exclusion in 2001 and during most of the 2002 treatment period. Low summertime CH4 uptake rates were found only briefly in both control and exclusion plots during a natural late summer drought, when water contents below 0.15 g cm-3 may have caused water stress of methanotrophs in the A horizon. Because these soils are well drained, the exclusion treatment had little effect on A horizon water content between wetting events, and the effect of water stress was smaller and more brief than was the overall treatment effect on methane diffusion. Methane consumption rates were highest in the A horizon and showed a parabolic relationship between gravimetric water content and CH4 consumption, with maximum rate at 0.23 g H2O g-1 soil. On average, about 74% of atmospheric CH4 was consumed in the top 4-5 cm of the mineral soil. By contrast, little or no CH4 consumption occurred in the O horizon. Snow cover significantly reduced the uptake rate from December to March. Removal of snow enhanced CH4 uptake by about 700-1000%, resulting in uptake rates similar to those measured during the growing season. Soil temperatures had little effect on CH4 uptake as long as the mineral soil was not frozen, indicating strong substrate limitation of methanotrophs throughout the year. Our results suggest that the extension of snow periods may affect the annual rate of CH4 oxidation and that summer droughts may increase the soil CH4 sink of temperate forest soils. ?? 2005 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.

Explore related subjects

Soil Biology and Biochemistry Article

Keep this discovery

Explore connections, maps & timelines

BibTeX RIS

W. Borken, E.A. Davidson, K. Savage, E.T. Sundquist, P. Steudler. 2006. Effect of summer throughfall exclusion, summer drought, and winter snow cover on methane fluxes in a temperate forest soil. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.soilbio.2005.10.011

Cite the original work for its findings. Save a collection to share your selection of sources.

KEEP EXPLORING

Related USGS reports

USGS2022

Mechanisms for retention of low molecular weight organic carbon varies with soil depth at a coastal prairie ecosystem

Though primary sources of carbon (C) to soil are plant inputs (e.g., rhizodeposits), the role of microorganisms as mediators of soil organic carbon (SOC) retention is increasingly recognized. Yet, insufficient knowledge of sub-soil processes complicates attempts to describe microbial-driven C cycling at depth as most studies of microbial-mineral-C interactions focus on surface horizons. We leveraged a well-studied paleo-marine terrace (90 ka) located near Santa Cruz, CA, to characterize the short-term (days to weeks) and intermediate-term (months to years) fate of two low molecular weight organic carbon. compounds at three depths in the soil profile (∼25 cm, A horizon; ∼75 cm A/B transition; and ∼125 cm, B horizon). We employed isotopically-labeled glucose (GLU) and oxalic acid (OXA) to represent two common classes of rhizodeposits: carbohydrates and organic acids. Using a combination of laboratory (9 d) and field (490 d) incubations, we traced the fate of GLU-C and OXA-C through dissolved-, metal-associated-, and microbially-respired CO2 and bulk SOC pools. Our results suggest new SOC retention (i.e., defined as 13C label identified in solid or aqueous fractions) over intermediate time frames (490 d) is correlated with patterns in short-term (9 d) cycling dynamics, which in turn is related to the theoretical efficiency by which microorganisms process each substrate. For all horizons (A, A/B, and B) GLU-C was converted to CO2 more quickly than OXA-C with modeled decomposition rates ∼2–4 times faster for GLU depending on microbial density (higher in A than B horizon). The faster decomposition rates of GLU-C increased fractional recovery (0.399 ± 0.026 to 0.504 ± 0.030 for GLU-C) compared to OXA-C (0.035 ± 0.003 to 0.127 ± 0.010) among all horizons in our field experiment (490 d). Though the overall proportion of GLU-C recovered in solid fractions did not vary significantly with horizon, based on 13C recovered in aqueous fractions the apparent mechanism for retention did. After the 9-d laboratory incubation, fractional recovery for GLU-C among C pools associated with microbial biomass was almost 20× higher than OXA-C (0.192 versus 0.010, respectively across all horizons). More than a year later, 43–46% of GLU-C retained in the field incubation was extractable with a neutral salt (representing a pool of soil C residing within or available to microbial biomass) among A and A/B horizons, while only 6% of retained GLU-C was similarly extractable in the B horizon. Thus, it appears among depths with higher microbial density (A, A/B horizons), anabolic recycling is the most likely process contributing to the persistence of glucose C, whereas abiotic sinks contributed more to intermediate-term stability for GLU-C in the B horizon. By contrast, most OXA-C was lost, presumably as CO2, over the short-term from the A and A/B horizons (fractional recovery: 0.136 ± 0.011 and 0.091 ± 0.002, respectively). However, though substantially lower than GLU-C recovered at the conclusion of our field experiment, the fraction of oxalic acid C retained in the B horizon over both short- (0.72 ± 0.037) and intermediate-time (0.127 ± 0.010) frames was several-fold higher than for overlying horizons. The specific process(es) (e.g., more efficient microbial utilization, metal-organic complexation, direct adsorption to the mineral matrix, etc.) contributing to higher retention for OXA-C at depth are discussed but remain unresolved.

Soil Biology and Biochemistry↗

USGS2022

The influence of soil development on the depth distribution and structure of soil microbial communities.

Although it has been shown that the interaction of climate and time shape the dynamics of soil organic matter (SOM) storage and preservation in soil, the role of soil microbial communities in this dynamic remains unclear. Microbial communities are present throughout soil profiles and likely play critical roles in SOM and nutrient cycling, however the influence of other factors such as soil development (i.e., age) and the composition SOM on microbial community variation with depth has yet to be quantified. Improving our understanding of the relationship between soil development, soil depth, and microbial communities may provide insight to the critical role they play in cycling and preservation of SOM, as well as more mechanistic predictions of the response of soil communities to change, such as landscape-scale changes in available moisture or temperature regimes. Here we compare soils spanning a soil age by climate gradient (i.e., climo-chronosequence) to better understand the mechanisms which influence soil microbial community structure and the molecular composition of SOM. While we observed little depth-dependence in metrics of microbial community structure (i.e., composition, diversity, dissimilarity) across the range of soil development under a wetter climate, we found significant depth-dependent changes in community metrics under a drier climate, which became more pronounced as soils became older. This shift in bacterial and archaeal community structure and diversity is most apparent below a clay-rich argillic horizon formed in the older, drier soils. The molecular composition of SOM as measured by high resolution mass spectrometry (i.e., FTICR MS) also exhibited similar shifts in composition with soil depth and age. Our results highlight how soil moisture shapes the interaction of soil development, SOM, and microbial community composition. Differences in the moisture regime between our two study sites drives differences in biogeochemical depth gradients and subsequent variation in soil microbes and SOM. This suggests that knowledge of not just the pedogenic trajectory of soil development, but also the spatial position relative to distinct pedogenic features, are important for explaining variations in the depth-dependencies of microbial communities and associated SOM.

California↗

USGS2021

Warming and microbial uptake influence the fate of added soil carbon across a Hawai'ian weathering gradient

Tropical forest soils contain some of the largest carbon (C) stocks on Earth, yet the effects of warming on the fate of fresh C entering tropical soils are still poorly understood. This research sought to understand how the fate of fresh C entering soils is influenced by warming, soil weathering status, and C chemistry. We hypothesized that compounds that are quickly incorporated into microbial biomass (i.e., greater C use efficiency [CUE]) subsequently have longer-term (255 days) retention in soil. We also hypothesized that relatively weathered soils with greater sorptive capacity also retain more fresh C in the short and longer-terms, and that C in these soils is more resistant to weathering loss compared with less weathered soils. We tested these hypotheses by adding two 13 C-labeled compounds (glucose and glycine) to three tropical forest soils from a weathering gradient in Hawai'i, and then incubating soils at ambient (16 °C), +5 °C, and +10 °C for 255 days. We found that 255-day 13 C retention in mineral soil across sites and temperatures was best predicted by two factors: initial retention of 13 C in mineral soil and initial microbial 13 CUE (Adjusted R 2 = 0.78). Carbon compound type influenced 13 C initial retention, with greater glucose- 13 C retention versus glycine- 13 C retention in mineral soils and microbial biomass, corresponding to greater glucose- 13 C retention in soil at 255 days. Warming had a negative longer-term effect on the retention of 13 C only in the least-weathered soil, supporting our hypothesis. These results show that initial retention of fresh C in soils via mineral sorption and microbial uptake is a strong predictor of longer-term retention, indicating that immediate C losses are a major hurdle for soil C storage. Also, retention of fresh C appears most sensitive to warming in less-weathered tropical soils, supporting the idea that mineral sorption may provide some protections against warming. Understanding the interaction between soil sorptive properties and warming for C cycling could improve predictions of forest-climate feedbacks for tropical regions.

Soil Biology and Biochemistry↗