The geology of a part of Acadia and the nature of the Acadian orogeny across Central and Eastern Maine

Abstract

The zone of Acadian collision between the Medial New England and Composite Avalon terranes is well preserved in Maine. A transect from northwest (Rome) to southeast (Camden) crosses the eastern part of Medial New England comprising the Central Maine basin, Liberty-Orrington thrust sheet, and Fredericton trough, and the western part of Composite Avalon, including the Graham Lake, Clarry Hill, and Clam Cove thrust sheets. U-Pb geochronology of events before, during, and after the Acadian orogeny helps elucidate the nature and distribution of tectonostratigraphic belts in this zone and the timing of some Acadian events in the Northern Appalachians. The Central Maine basin consists of sedimentary and volcanic rocks of Middle Ordovician (∼470 to ∼460 Ma) age overlain with probable conformity by latest Ordovician(?) through earliest Devonian marine rift and flysch sedimentary rocks; these are intruded by weakly to undeformed plutonic rocks of Early and Middle Devonian age (∼399–378 Ma). The Fredericton trough consists of Early Silurian gray pelite and sandstone to earliest Late Silurian calcareous turbidite, deformed and variably metamorphosed prior to the emplacement of Late Silurian (∼422 Ma) and Early to Late Devonian (∼418 to ∼368 Ma) plutons. The Liberty-Orrington thrust sheet consists of Cambrian(?)-Ordovician (>∼474 to ∼469 Ma and younger) clastic sedimentary and volcanic rocks intruded by highly deformed Late Silurian (∼424 to ∼422 Ma) and Devonian (∼418 to ∼389 Ma) plutons, possibly metamorphosed in Late Silurian time (prior to ∼417 Ma), and metamorphosed to amphibolite facies in Early to Middle Devonian time (∼400 to ∼381 Ma). The Graham Lake thrust sheet contains possible Precambrian rocks, Cambrian sedimentary rocks with a volcanic unit dated at ∼503 Ma, and Ordovician rocks with possible Caradocian Old World fossils, metamorphosed and deformed in Silurian time and intruded by mildly to undeformed Late Silurian (∼421 Ma) and Late Devonian (∼371 to ∼368 Ma) plutons. The Clarry Hill thrust sheet consists of poorly studied, highly metamorphosed Cambrian (?) rocks. The Clam Cove thrust sheet contains highly deformed Precambrian limestone, shale, sandstone, and conglomerate, metamorphosed to epidote amphibolite facies and intruded by a mildly deformed pluton dated at ∼421 Ma. Metamorphism, deformation, and voluminous intrusive igneous activity of Silurian age are common to both the most southeastern parts of Medial New England and the thrust sheets of Composite Avalon. In contrast to Medial New England, the thrust sheets of Composite Avalon show only modest effects of Devonian deformation and metamorphism. Regional stratigraphic relations, paleontologic findings, and U-Pb geochronology suggest that the Graham Lake, Clarry Hill, and Clam Cove thrust sheets are far-traveled allochthons that were widely separated from Medial New England in the Silurian. One hundred nine (109) new U-Pb analyses of zircon, monazite, and sphene from 25 samples of metamorphosed, stratified, and intrusive igneous rocks are used to decipher the history of events along the transect. In our view, many of the structures within Medial New England were formed during the closing of the back-arc ocean during the waning stages of the Taconian orogeny. These features include the precursors to the upright folds found in Silurian sedimentary rocks, the west-facing Liberty-Orrington thrust sheet, and the Silurian plutons of Medial New England. Acadian tectonic features, including flysch sedimentation, igneous activity, deformation with nappe emplacement, and metamorphism record the progressive loading of Medial New England by a stack of thrust nappes emplaced in latest Silurian to Middle Devonian time. The Acadian orogeny is a prolonged event, lasting from earliest Late Silurian to the Late Devonian, whose evolution involved: (1) convergence between Medial New England and Composite Avalon along an east-dipping subduction zone from earliest Late Silurian to Early Devonian time; (2) collision and concurrent delamination of lithospheric mantle beneath Medial New England in Early Devonian time resulting in deformation, high-grade metamorphism, and intrusive igneous activity in the most eastern part of Medial New England and the western parts of Composite Avalon; (3) Early to Middle Devonian northwest-migrating penetrative deformations of the Acadian Main stage, including northwest-directed thrusting and recumbent folding followed by tightening of folds possibly produced in the waning stages of the Taconian orogeny and forming folded wave trains of isoclinal folds (∼419 to ∼404 Ma), (4) asymmetrical folds produced by east-west shortening (∼399 to ∼380 Ma); and (5) final westward emplacement of Composite Avalon thrust sheets onto Medial New England in Late Devonian time (∼380 to ∼371 Ma). The present boundary between rocks of Medial New England and Composite Avalon at the surface is the Sennebec Pond fault, a high-angle fault that cuts the Graham Lake and Clarry Hill thrusts, and is intruded by the Mt. Waldo pluton (∼371), one of several Late Devonian plutons (∼371 to ∼367 Ma) that mark the end of the Acadian orogeny in coastal Maine. The thrust sheets of Composite Avalon carried rocks of peri-Gondwanan affinity and with possible Old World fauna many kilometers to the west over Medial New England, thus potentially hiding the original suture at depth under the Gulf of Maine.