Reply to “Ranking filter methods for concentrating pathogens in lake water”
Accurately comparing filtration methods is indeed difficult. Our method ( 1 ) and the method described by Borchardt et al. for determining recoveries are both acceptable approaches; however, each is designed to achieve a different research goal. Our study was designed to compare recoveries of multiple microorganisms in surface-water samples. Because, in practice, water-matrix effects come into play throughout filtration, concentration, and detection processes, we felt it important to incorporate those effects into the recovery results.
Applied and Environmental Microbiology↗