Return rates of GPS-tagged Pacific Golden-Plovers: A controlled study in Hawaii
In a study of GPS-tagged Pacific Golden-Plovers wintering at Moorea, French Polynesia, Johnson et al. (2020) raised questions about possible tag-induced mortality. Similar concerns in other species have generated considerable attention in recent years. Of 19 tagged plovers that departed Moorea on northward migration, only one bird (5 %) uploaded a complete migratory cycle to Argos. Furthermore, contact was lost with 12 birds (63 %) variously during overwater flight, at stopover sites, or on nesting grounds; and no signals at all were received from 6 individuals (32%). Such observations suggest that carrying a tag might be a life-threatening burden. We cannot exclude the possibility that tag weight caused difficulties for the Moorea birds. However, this seems an unlikely factor in that the device (tag plus harness) being carried weighed less than 3 % of body mass (see beyond). Such a load is in accord with generally accepted albeit arbitrary limits. Other tag-associated concerns such as altered aerodynamics, increased vulnerability to predation, and (given the complex nature of geomagnetic navigation, the possibility that tag electronics might interfere with sense of direction, are more difficult to evaluate. Alternatively, loss of contact with tagged birds may be simply a matter of tag malfunction, battery failure, or a broken harness. To shed light on these uncertainties, and to explore the survival of GPS-tagged plovers on a nonbreeding ground in Hawaii, we conducted a controlled study using birds that winter in the National Memorial Cemetery of the Pacific (known locally as the Punchbowl).